Unmasking the machine: A critical reflection on evaluating AI-generated content in a pedagogical setting
Written By: Author(s): James Rawbone
4 min read
JAMES RAWBONE, HEAD OF ADDITIONAL EDUCATIONAL NEEDS, ST LAWRENCE COLLEGE, UK
Pontius Pilate once asked, ‘What is truth?’. An answer to such a question is beyond the remit of this article; Benjamin Freud (2025) reminds us that as teachers, however, it is important that we can be confident that the material we present to our students is trustworthy and reliable.
How much can we trust the content generated by AI (artificial intelligence)? A couple of years ago I asked ChatGPT to create a scheme of work for British History from 1066–1500. To my surprise ‘The Glorious Revolution’ was included, which did not take place until 1688. No system is perfect, and hallucinations, or mistakes, are a feature of AI-generated content. There is, however, a deeper concern; Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained by scraping the internet for knowledge, thereby replicating much of the confused thinking on the internet, with its inherent bias, logical fallacies and outright prejudices. As an e
Join us or sign in now to view the rest of this page
You're viewing this site as a guest, which only allows you to view a limited amount of content.
To view this page and get access to all our resources, join the Chartered College of Teaching (it's free for trainee teachers and half price for ECTs) or log in if you're already a member.
References
- Aristotle (2015) Sophistical refutations. Available at: https://www.loebclassics.com/view/aristotle-sophistical_refutations/1955/pb_LCL400.11.xml [accessed 13.1.25]
- Keeney J (2025) AI bias examples and how to check AI content for biases. Available at https://contentwriters.com/blog/check-ai-content-bias-examples/ [accessed 23.7.25].Glaser EM (1941) An Experiment in the Development of Critical Thinking. Teacher’s College, Columbia University.
- Hruschka TMJ and Appel M (2023) Learning about informal fallacies and the detection of fake news: An experimental intervention. PLOS ONE 18(3):e0283238. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0283238
- Freud B, From post-truth to post-trust. International Schools Network. Available at https://isn.education/articles/open/from-post-truth-to-post-trust/?utm_campaign=2079610_ISN%20monthly%20newsletter%20-%20Feb&utm_medium=email&utm_source=International%20Schools%20Network&dm_i=6U3A,18KMY,2H7QE7,4RD8Q,1 [accessed 18.4.25]
- Paul R (2012) Critical Thinking: What Every Person Needs to Survive in a Rapidly Changing World. California, Foundation for Critical Thinking in Tomales.
- Shiveley J M and Vanfossen PJ (1999) Critical thinking and the internet: Opportunities for the social studies classroom. The Social Studies. 90(1), 42–46.
- Porter T, Elnakouri A, Meyers EA, Shibayama T, Jayawickreme E and Grossmann I (2022) Predictors and consequences of intellectual humility. Nat Rev Psychol. 2022;1(9):524–536.
- SERP AI Logical fallacies. Available at https://serp.ai/posts/logical-fallacies/ [accessed 24.5.25].
- Vincent-Lancrin S (2023) Fostering and assessing student critical thinking. European Journal of Education Research, Development and Policy. 58(3): 354–68.
Subscribe
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Oldest
